Correspondence Address:
Dr.Naikwadi Ganesh Assistant Professor, Dept of Strirog Prasuti tantra, S.S.T. Ayurved college, Sangamner.Dist.Ahmednagar.
Date of Acceptance: 2023-09-14
Date of Publication:2023-10-10
Article-ID:AYU_98_10_23 https://ayuscript.com
Source of Support: Nill
Conflict of Interest: None declared
How To Cite This Article: Naikwadi G.A., Gore M.B., Moule C.M., Mahale G.V., Bombale A.B. A Randomized Clinical Trial to Evaluate the Effect of Jambu Beej Churna in And Nagkeshar Churna in Treating Raktapradara. AYUSCRIPT 2023;2(3):42-53 DOI: http://doi.org/10.55552/AYUSCRIPT.2023.2305
Background: The word Artava denotes two meanings one of them is ‘Antah Pushpa’ i.e., ovum and another one is ‘Bahir Pushpa’ Menstrual flow (Rajastrava). Both Antah and Bahir Pushpa are interrelated. Bahir Pushpa is outward manifestation of appropriate work of Antah Pushpa which is necessary for conception. Aim & Objective: To evaluate the effect of Jambu beej churna and Nagkeshar churna in treating Raktapradara. To achive reduction in duration and quantity of per vaginal bleeding in Raktapradara. Methods: Female patients complaining mainly of Raktapradar were selected irrespective of Age, Sex, occupation, religion, and prakruti. Total duration of the Treatment is for 03 successive menstrual cycles. Thus, Observations and Investigations necessary would be carried on the 1st, 3rd, 7th, 10th, 15th day of first menstrual cycle and then on 5th day of next 2 menstrual. Results & Conclusion: It can be concluded that Jambu beej Churna (Trial drug) is quite effective on Raktapradar. Nagkeshar churna (Control drug) is found efficacious in comparison with Jambu beej Churna in Raktapradar disease. Nagkeshar Churna shows better Statistical results than the Trial drug.
KEYWORDS: Raktapradar,Nagkeshar churna, Jambu beej churna
The health of Nation mainly depends on the health of woman because the healthy and happy woman lays the first step of aprosperous nation. Any feeling of physical or psychological factor directly affects her attitude and efficacy which adversely affects the family. Ayurveda has given principal significance to women health it has mentioned menstrual cycle as “Rutuchakra” and menses is phrased as “Rajastrava”. Impressive explanation of “Shuddha Raja” (Normal menstrual flow) has been imposed by our Acharya’s. The word Artava denotes two meanings one of them is ‘Antah Pushpa’ i.e., ovum and another one is ‘Bahir Pushpa’ Menstrual flow (Rajastrava). Both Antah and Bahir Pushpa are interrelated. Bahir Pushpa is an outward manifestation of appropriate work of Antah Pushpa which is necessary for conception. Here, the present study deals with Bahir Pushpa that is menstrual blood. Menstruation is a natural physical specific property of a female and so, it called as monthly period.Artava or Mentrual blood is expelled from the uterus through vagina in biological rhythm of women during her reproductive period i.e. from menarche to menopause. During daily medical practice we often come across different gynecological complaints e.g- Yonigat shwet strav, Yoni kandu, Yoni dah etc. Among which”Raktapradar” is much common, it affects the whole efficacy of woman. Maharashi Charka have described that treatment of Raktapradara is similar to that of Raktatisara, Raktapitta and Raktarsha various herbs, herbal compounds, metallic compounds and medical regimens are prescribed in the management of above conditions as haemostatic or Raktastambhaka attributes should be employed in Raktapradara. If Raktapradar is untreated it can lead to major suffering for the women and can hamper her day-to-day activities more over it can cause severe anaemia which can further debilitate the patient hence prompt and effective treatment is required in Raktapradara. Due to limitation of medical therapy as well surgical therapy of modern science, it becomes the necessity of the time to find out an efficational harmless therapy to manage the condition. As Jambu beej churna are easy to available or easy to prepare, they are also coast effective and easy to consume also. Jambu Beej churna is used as haemostatic and in various vaginal condtions Nagkeshara is also one of trusted drug used in various bleeding conditions.
B) Inclusion Criteria: -
C) Exclusion Criteria: -
D) Place of work: - This study was carried out in our Hospital’s OPD of Stree Roga Prasuti Tantra.
E) Informed Consent: - The subject undergoing this study was informed about the nature & purpose of study and written consent for each patient in both groups was taken.
F) Material: [Drugs]
Jambu beej churna –Trial Drug.
Nagkeshar churna –Control Drug
G) Methods [Treatment Schedule]: – The selected patient will be treated under following groups
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS: -
The information collected on the basis of observation, were subjected to statistical analysis in terms of percentage of relief, Mean, Standard Deviation (SD) and variance and by the use of unpaired t test, evaluate the significances at different levels i.e., at 0.05, 0.01 and 0.001 levels. The obtained results were interpreted as-
Data: - The data of patients is collected before treatment that is day 1st and the data collected after giving Jambu Beej Churna for 3 cycles of each patient.
Test: - For this study unpaired t test was applied.
Null Hypothesis: - There is no change in the data or symptoms score obtained before and after the treatment. So, Jambu Beej Churna is not effective in the Raktapradara.
Alternative Hypothesis: - The score of the symptoms is reduced after giving Jambu Beej Churna. So, Jambu Beej Churna is effective in the Raktapradara.
In the observation of Duration of PV bleeding, in Group A- Mean is 0.2, SD is 0.4068 & variance is 0.1655 and in group B-Mean is 0.4667, SD is 0.5713, variance is 0.3264, by unpaired t-test,P is less than 0.05, it means significant difference observed in Group A than Group B.
In the observation of Total Blood loss according to avg. wt. of soaked pad during, in Group A- Mean is 0.1333, SD is 0.3457 & variance is 0.1195 and in group B-Mean is 0.5333, SD is 0.5713 & variance is 0.3264, by unpaired t-test, P is less than 0.05, it means significant difference observed in Group A than Group B.
In observation of Abdomen pain,in Group A-Mean is 0.1667,SD is 0.3791 & variance is 0.1437 and in Group B-Mean is 0.4667, SD is 0.6288 & variance is 0.3954 , by unpaired t-test, P is less than 0.05, it means significant difference observed in Group A than Group B.
In the observation of HB%, in Group A-Mean is 0.2667, SD is 0.4498 & Variance is 0.2023 and in Group B-Mean is 0.5667, SD is 0.6261 & variance is 0.392, by unpaired t-test, P is less than 0.05, it means significant difference observed in Group A than Group B.
In the observation of Katishool, in Group A-Mean is 0.1, SD is 0.3051 & variance is 0.0,0931 and in Group B-Mean is 0.3667, SD is 0.4901 & variance is 0.2402, by unpaired t-test, P is less than 0.05, it means significant difference observed in Group A than Group B.
In the observation of Agnimandya, in Group A-Mean is 0.1333, SD is 0.3457 & variance is 0.1195 and in Group B-Mean is 0.4667, SD is 0.5713 & variance is 0.3264, by unpaired t-test, P is less than 0.05, it means significant difference observed in Group A than Group B.
RESULTS: -
From the above data analysis, it found that there is change in the score of symptoms before treatment and after treatment, that is the score is decreased and patients getting relief so the null hypothesis is rejected and alternative hypothesis is accepted that is Jambu Beej Churna shows highly significant results on Raktapradar.
Raja is an important factor for women. Shuddha raja or Artava is one of the most essential factors for healthy progeny, it gives the starting of reproductive period.
DURATION OF PV BLEEDING: - In Group-A of Jambu beej Churna, duration of PV bleeding shows relief 80% which is statistically highly significant. While in Group-B of NagkesharChurnashows relief 56.66% which is statistically significant. Hence by using statistical test difference between the mean of two groups when compared with each other shows that Group-A is more effective on duration of PV bleeding than Group-B.
TOTAL BLOOD LOSS ACCORDING TO AVERAGE WEIGHT OF SOAKED PAD DURING MENSTRIAL CYCLE: - In Group-A of Jambu beej churna, Quantity of PV bleeding shows relief 86.66 % which is statistically highly significant. While in Group-B of NagkesharChurnashows relief 50 % which is statistically significant.
ABDOMINAL PAIN: - In Group-A of Jambu Beej Churna, Abdominal Pain shows relief 83.33 % which is statistically highly significant. While in Control Group-B of NagkesharChurna shows relief 60 % which is statistically significant. Hence by using statistical test difference between the mean of two groups when compared with each other shows that Group-A is more effective on Abdominal pain than Group-B.
Hemoglobin %- In Group-A of Jambu Beej Churna, Heamoglobin shows relief 73.33% which is statistically highly significant. While in Control Group-B of Nagkeshar Churna shows relief 50% which is statistically significant.
1)Shribhava Misra, Edited by Sri Brahmasankara Misra & Sri Rupalalji Vaisya Chaukhambha Sanskrit Bhawan, Varanasi - 221001 Bhavaprakash 11th edition, 2007
2)Agnivesh. Elaborated by Charak & redacted by Dradhabala edited by Acharya Vidyadhar Shukla & Prof. Ravi Datta Tripathi Chaukambha Sanskrit Prathishthan,
Delhi – 110007 Charaksamhita Reprint 2011
3)Maharshi Sushruta, edited by Kaviraj Ambikadatta Shastri, Chaukhambha Sanskrit Sansthan,Varanasi Sushrut Samhita Reprint 2012
4)Maharashi Vagbhata, Commentory by Sarvangsundar of Arudatta Ayurvediya Rasayana of Hemadri Chaukhamba orientalid, Varanashi Ashtanghridaya Reprint 2011
5)Aacharya Sharngadhar, edited by Dr. Smt. Shailaja Shrivastava Chaukhambha Orientalia, Varanasi – 221001 Sharngadhar Samhita Reprint 2011
6)Prof. Priyavrat Sharma Chaukhambha Bharti Academy, Varanasi-221001 Dravya guna vidnyan Reprint 2006
7)Prof. Premvati Tivari Chaukhambha Orientalia, Varanasi-221001 Ayurvediya Prasutitantra Avum Streerog 2nd edition, Reprint 2011
8)D.C. Dutta edited by Hiralal Konar New Central Book Agency (P) Ltd. Calcutta- 700009 Text Book of Obstetrics 6th edition,
Reprint 2009
9)B.K. Mahajan Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers (P) Ltd, New Delhi–110002 Methods in Biostatics 7th edition, 2010
10)Vagbhatacharya, edited by Sarvangasundar by Dr. Ganesh Krishna Garde Rajesh Prakashan, Kothrud, Pune – 38 Sartha Vagbhata 2009.